This article is provided for educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal, financial, or tax advice, and no attorney-client relationship is formed by reading it. Laws, regulations, official guidance, and related information vary by jurisdiction, change frequently, and may have changed or become outdated since the publication date. Always verify current information with authoritative sources and consult a qualified professional about your specific circumstances. The author and publisher assume no liability for actions taken based on this information.
Key Facts
- Federal and state: To arbitrate means to submit a dispute to a neutral decision-maker outside the ordinary court trial process for a decision called an award.
- Federal and state: Arbitration authority ordinarily comes from an agreement, while state contract law often governs whether the parties formed a valid agreement.
- Federal level: The Federal Arbitration Act supports enforcement of covered written agreements but does not automatically create federal subject-matter jurisdiction.
- Federal level: Federal courts may stay litigation, compel covered arbitration, confirm an award, or vacate it on limited statutory grounds when jurisdiction and statutory requirements exist.
- Federal and state: Arbitration differs from mediation because an arbitrator decides; a mediator ordinarily helps parties negotiate without imposing a decision.
To arbitrate means to present a dispute to one or more neutral arbitrators for decision instead of asking a judge or jury to decide the merits at a conventional trial. The process ends in an arbitration award, which may determine liability, money, or another remedy within the arbitrator’s authority.
“Arbitrated” simply describes a dispute that was submitted to arbitration. It does not reveal whether arbitration was voluntary after the dispute, required by an earlier contract, administered by an organization, or compelled by a court.
Arbitration is based on agreement
Arbitration is fundamentally contractual. The agreement defines which disputes are covered, the number or selection of arbitrators, applicable rules, location, available remedies, and other procedural terms.
In First Options of Chicago, Inc. v. Kaplan, the Supreme Court explained that ordinary state-law principles generally govern whether parties formed an arbitration agreement. Courts do not assume that parties delegated the gateway question of arbitrability to an arbitrator without clear and unmistakable evidence.
The Federal Arbitration Act supplies enforcement tools
Section 2 of the Federal Arbitration Act makes covered written arbitration agreements enforceable, subject to generally applicable contract-revocation grounds and statutory exceptions. This federal rule interacts with state contract law rather than replacing every formation or validity principle.
Section 3 addresses a pending federal lawsuit containing an issue referable to arbitration. On a qualifying application, the court stays the trial while arbitration proceeds under the agreement.
Section 4 permits a petition to compel arbitration in a federal district court that would otherwise have subject-matter jurisdiction over the controversy. The FAA alone does not automatically open the federal courthouse.
The hearing differs from a court trial
Arbitration commonly includes written claims and responses, arbitrator selection, information exchange, evidentiary submissions, a hearing, and an award. The details depend on the agreement, governing law, administrator rules, and arbitrator orders.
Arbitration is distinct from mediation. An arbitrator decides the submitted dispute; a mediator ordinarily facilitates negotiations while the parties control whether to settle.
An award is not an ordinary appealable judgment
An arbitration award does not automatically become a court judgment. FAA section 9 provides a confirmation mechanism when its conditions are satisfied, and a confirmed award can be enforced as a judgment.
Judicial review is limited. Section 10 identifies grounds such as corruption, evident partiality, prejudicial hearing misconduct, or arbitrators exceeding their powers. It does not authorize a full retrial merely because a party disputes the arbitrator’s reasoning.
Section 16 separately controls appeals from federal orders involving arbitration. Some orders denying arbitration are immediately appealable, while specified interlocutory orders favoring arbitration generally are not.
Administration and governing law still matter
An institution such as the American Arbitration Association may administer a case under selected rules, but the administrator is not the source of every party’s legal obligation to arbitrate. The obligation ordinarily depends on the agreement and governing law.
States maintain their own arbitration statutes and contract doctrines. Federal preemption may affect conflicting state rules, but the FAA does not convert every arbitration dispute into a federal case or create a single procedure for every agreement.